Ecole Internationale Daniel Chalonge   

13th Paris Cosmology Colloquium 2009


George Smoot, Nobel Prize of Physics and Daniel Chalonge Medal

Observatoire de Paris, Paris campus

Thursday 23 , Friday 24 and Saturday 25 July 2009

Programme and Time Table (.pdf)

Practical informations

Click to download the poster (.pdf)

Programme and Lectures (.pdf)

List of Registered Participants (.pdf)

Album Photos

Highlights and Conclusions of the Colloquium (.pdf)

Highlights and Conclusions


The Conference is within the astrofundamental physics spirit of the Chalonge School, this time focalized on recent observational and theoretical progress on the CMB, dark matter, dark energy, dark ages, and the theory of the early universe with predictive power in the context of the Standard Model of the Universe..

In summary, the aim of the meeting is to put together real cosmological data and hard theory predictive approach connected to them in the framework of the Standard Model of th Universe.

Topics: Observational and theoretical progress in deciphering the nature of dark matter, dark energy, dark ages and the 21 cm line. Large and small scale structure formation. Inflation after WMAP (in connection with the CMB and LSS data),slow roll and fast roll inflation, quadrupole suppression and initial conditions; quantum effects. CMB polarization, primordial magnetic fields effects. Neutrinos in cosmology.
All Lectures are followed by a discussion. All participants are invited to take part in the discussions.

The Meeting is open to all scientists interested in the subject.Registration is mandatory. Registration information is given below.

The format of the Meeting is intended to allow easy and fruitful mutual contact and communication.

Sessions last for three days in the beautiful parisian campus of Observatoire de Paris (built on orders from Colbert and to plans by Claude Perrault from 1667 to 1672). All sessions take place at the "Salle du Conseil" (Council Room) in the historic Perrault building ("Bâtiment Perrault") of Observatoire de Paris HQ, under the portraits of Laplace, Le Verrier, Lalande, Arago, Delambre and Louis XIV.

In the case participants are numerous enough as last year, Sessions will take place in the Salle Cassini (Cassini Hall), just upstairs Salle du Conseil

An exhibition will retrace the 18 years of activity of the Chalonge School and George Smoot participation to the School along these 18 years.

The books and proceedings of the School since its creation, as well as historic Daniel Chalonge material, and Chalonge instruments will be on exhibition at the Great Gallery.

Informations on the previous Paris Cosmology Colloquia and of the school events are available at    (lecturers, lists of participants, lecture pdf files and photos during the Colloquia).


Tom ABEL (Stanford Univ., Physics Dept. CA. USA)
First Galaxies and Cosmological Reionization.

Nicola BARTOLO (INFN Univ Padova, Italy)
Primordial Non-Gaussianity and the CMB in the Standard Model of the Universe (I.)

Peter BIERMANN (MPI-Bonn, Germany & Univ of Alabama, Tuscaloosa, USA)
Ultra High Energy Particles in the Universe

James BULLOCK (University of California, Irvine, USA)
Milky Way Satellites: Near Field Cosmology with the Most Dark Matter Dominated Galaxies in the Universe.

Asantha COORAY(University of California, Irvine, USA)
Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect Angular Power Spectrum : Measurements with BOOMERanG and Theoretical Comparisons

Claudio DESTRI (INFN Univ. Milano-Bicocca Dpt. di Fisica, Italy)
New Monte Carlo Markov Chain Analysis of CMB +LSS data with the Effective Theory of Inflation and the Early Fast-Roll Stage.

Hector J. DE VEGA (CNRS LPTHE Univ de Paris VI, France)
The Effective Theory of Inflation and the Early Fast-Roll Stage, Dark Matter and Dark Energy in the Standard Model of the Universe

Carlos S. FRENK (Institute for Computational Cosmology, Durham, UK)
Large and Small Scale Structure in the Standard Model of the Universe

Gerard F. GILMORE (nstitute of Astronomy, Cambridge University, UK)
Properties of Dark Matter on Small Astrophysical Scale

Massimo GIOVANNINI (INFN Univ. Milano-Bicocca Dpt. di Fisica, Italy)
Cosmological Magnetic Fields in the Standard Model of the Universe

Alexander KASHLINSKY (NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD, USA)
Probing large-scale peculiar flows of clusters of galaxies.

Eiichiro KOMATSU (Univ of Texas, Dept of Astronomy, Austin, USA)
How WMAP Helps Constrain the Nature of Dark Energy

Anthony N. LASENBY (Cavendish Laboratory, Cambridge, UK)
The CMB in the Standard Model of the Universe: A Status Report

Reno MANDOLESI (INAF-IASF, Bologna, Italy)
Measurements of the CMB by the PLANCK satellite and their Implications

Sabino MATARRESE (INFN Univ Padova, Italy)
Primordial Non-Gaussianity and the CMB in the Standard Model of the Universe(II).

Paolo SALUCCI (SISSA-Astrophysics, Trieste, Italy)
The Dark Matter Surface Density in Galaxies and Cored Density Profiles

Norma G. SANCHEZ (CNRS LERMA Observatoire de Paris, France)
Understanding of Inflation and the Early Fast-Roll Stage, Dark Matter and Dark Energy in the Standard Model of the Universe

Paul R. SHAPIRO (Univ of Texas, Dept of Astronomy, Austin, USA)
Reionization History of the Universe and the 21cm Background

George SMOOT (LBL, Univ. of California, Berkeley, USA)
CMB Observations and the Standard Model of the Universe



Local and practical information can be found below.


The Meeting is open to all scientists interested in the subject but Registration is mandatory. Registration fee is 50 Euros. The registration fee covers the 6 coffee breaks, the tickets for 3 lunchs and the cocktail/reception. The registration fee must be paid cash to the Secretary (not by credit card, nor by check) at the registrationdesk on the 1st day of the Colloquium (Thursday 23 July 2009).
Certificates of participation and receipts will be delivered by the Secretariat upon request.
Participants wishing to attend the Meeting should register in time, and in any case
Before 1st June 2009 , by on line registration.
An automatic mail of confirmation is sent to you after your on line enregistration.


The List of Registered confirmed Participants will be posted in June.Badges for all registered participants in the list will be available at the Registration from Thursday 23 July 8:10 am.
Please wear your badge all during the Colloquium, which will make easy your access and circulation within the campus.


Colloquium Secretariat:

We look forward to seeing you in Paris for a creative, fruitful and enjoying meeting.
Hotel reservations for the invited Lecturers and accompanying persons will be provided by the Colloquium organizers.


Welcome of the participants and Registration starts Thursday 23 July at 8:00 am at the “Grand Galerie” (Great Gallery) in the historic Perrault Building ("Bâtiment Perrault")

Lectures start on Thursday 23 July at 9:00 am at “Salle du Conseil” (Council Room) aside Grand Galerie in Perrault building . Tickets for lunch will be on sale at the registration desk from Thursday morning.

We shall stick strictly to the timetible during the whole meeting.

All sessions take place in the historic Perrault building ("Bâtiment Perrault"),

All COFFEE-TEA-MATE-CHAMPAGNE BREAKS take place in Cassini Hall (Salle Cassini) just upstairs the Council room in the Perrault building.

LUNCH is served at the Self-service Restaurant of Observatoire de Paris (located very near, inside the campus at Building B, ground floor). On Saturday 25 July, a Buffet will be served for Lunch at Cassini Hall (Salle Cassini) for all participants and accompanying persons.

The PHOTO of the group will be taken on the meridian of Paris in the middle of the monumental south entry of the Perrault building on Friday 24 July at the end of the afternoon session.

A TOUR of Perrault building for all participants and accompanying persons will take place on Saturday 25 July in the afternoon from 18:00 to 19:00, guided by Prof Suzanne DEBARBAT around a special subject and an exhibition choosen for the purpose).

A COCKTAIL/RECEPTION for all participants and accompanying persons will be offered on Saturday 25 July in the afternoon (from 19:00) in Cassini Hall (“Salle Cassini”) of Perrault building along the Meridean of Paris.

Please Notice: The Colloquium ends after the COCKTAIL/RECEPTION.

The entrance of the Observatoire de Paris is at 77, Avenue Denfert-Rochereau, Paris 75014.

[Notice that this differs from the postal address: 61, Avenue de l'Observatoire, Paris 75014, although they are nearby].

The nearest metro station is Denfert-Rochereau (100 m. approx). The RER station Port Royal is about the same distance. You can also reach the Observatoire with the buses 38, 91, 83 and Orlybus.

From the entry at 77, Avenue Denfert-Rochereau, once inside Observatoire, the "Salle de l'Atelier" is just located at the right, and in front of the new building B (''Bâtiment B"), where the Observatoire self-service restaurant is located.

From the entry at 77, Avenue Denfert-Rochereau, once inside Observatoire, to reach Bâtiment Perrault: enter the campus following the straigth road going to the old Coudé building and coupoles (the way one sees new " Bâtiment B ", and old " Ateliers des Artistes ") and continue the road (on the left) till the open central path from which (bordered by the trees), the monumental front south main entry of Perrault building is seen.

The " Salle du Conseil " is just at the left of the front south entry. " Grande Galerie " is aside facing Salle du Conseil. (is easy to find, and indications are placed.)

Lunch will be served at the Observatoire Self-Service Restaurant. It is located in the ground floor of building B ("Bâtiment B"). Tickets for lunch will be on sale at the Conference registration desk from Thursday morning.

The Observatoire Self-Service Restaurant is closed for dinner and on Saturdays /Sundays. On Saturday, it will be a special Buffet for lunch at Cassini Hall, and a Cocktail/Reception at the late afternoon.

Some Restaurants near Observatoire are listed below.



Longitude: 2°20' East

Latitude: 48°50' North

Entry: 77, Avenue Denfert-Rochereau, 75014 Paris

Subway Station : Denfert-Rochereau or Port Royal

Bus 38, 83 or 91 , stop at Observatoire Port-Royal

From Roissy (Charles de Gaulle) airport: Taxi or

Take the RER B (fast subburban train) up to Denfert-Rochereau

From Orly airport: Taxi or

Two solutions: 1.cheaper (Bus) or 2. faster and secure (Orly Val)

1. Take the OrlyBus up to Denfert-Rochereau or

2. Take the OrlyVal up to Antony then take RER B direction Paris up to Denfert-Rochereau



Hotel du Midi, 4, Av. René Coty, Paris 75014. Metro : Denfert-Rochereau

tel. 33(0).14327-2325. fax 33(0).14321-2458.

Double room, with shower, WC and TV. Double room with bathtube, WC and TV.

air conditioning, modem in bedrooms.



Hotel Beauvoir, 43, Av. George Bernanos, Paris 75005,

tel. 33(0).14325-5710, fax-33(0).14354-3187.

Single room. Double room. Twin double rooms. With shower, WC and TV (in

double rooms).



Hotel Pierre Nicole, 39, rue Pierre-Nicole, Paris 75005,

Tel.33 (0).1 4354-7686, fax 33(0).14354-2245.

Single room. Double room. With shower, WC and TV in all rooms.



Hotel L'Aiglon, 232 bd Raspail, Paris 75014,

Tel.33 (0).1 14320-8242, fax 33(0).14320-9872.

air conditioning, TV and modem in bedrooms.



Hotel Nouvel Orléans, 25 av. Gén. Leclerc, Paris 75014

Tel.33 (0). 14327-8020, fax 33(0).14335-3657.

air conditioning, TV and modem in bedrooms. Non-smoking bedrooms.



Mercure Raspail Montparnasse, 207 bd Raspail, Paris 75014

Tel.33 (0). 14320-6294, fax 33(0).14327-3969.

air conditioning, TV and modem in bedrooms. Non-smoking bedrooms.



Hotel Istria, 29 rue Campagne Première, Paris 75014

Tel.33 (0). 14320-9182, fax 33(0).14322-4845.

TV and modem in bedrooms.



Hotel Paix , 225 bd Raspail, Paris 75014

Tel.33 (0). 14320-3582, fax 33(0).14335-3263.

TV and modem in bedrooms.



Hotel Daguerre , 94 rue Daguerre, Paris 75014

Tel.33 (0). 14322-4354,

Single rooms, Double rooms, shower WC



Touring Hotel Magendie , 6 rue Corvisart, Paris 75013

Tel.33 (0). 14336-1361,

Single rooms, Double rooms, shower WC, garage




Hotel Floridor, 28, place Denfert-Rochereau, Paris 75014.

Tel. 33(0)1-4321-3553. Fax 33(0)1-4327-6581.

Single room. Double room. With shower, WC and TV. Breakfast.

Hotel des Voyageurs, 22 rue Boulard (near rue Daguerre), Paris 75014.

(Near place Denfert-Rochereau). Metro station: Denfert-Rochereau

Tel:(33-1) 43 21 08 20

Single room. Double room. Studio. With shower, WC and TV in all rooms.


Hotel de l'Espérance, 1, rue Grancey, Paris 75014. (Near place Denfert-Rochereau).

Tel. 33(0)1-4321-4104.

Single and double rooms with TV, shower and lavatory. Without shower in the room. Breakfast.


Colegio de España, Cité Universitaire de Paris,

7e Boulevard Jourdan, 75014 PARIS, Metro RER Station: Cité Universitaire.

Tel: 33(0) 1 40 78 32 00, Fax: 33(0) 1 45 80 39 58.


Fundación Argentina in the Cité Universitaire.

19, Boulevard Jourdan, Paris 75014, Metro RER Station Cité Universitaire.

Tel. 33(0)144162900, Fax 33(0)144162905.

Single room with lavatory.



La Marée Denfert, 83, Av. Denfert-Rochereau. Tel. 014354-9986. Open every day of the year for lunch and dinner.

Sea food and fish restaurant. 35 to 45 euros


Swann & Vincent , 22, pl. Denfert-Rochereau. Tel. 014321-2259. Open till 11.45 pm.

Italian restaurant (trattoria), Recommended dishes:

aubergines au gratin, sea bream (daurade) fillet with red peppers and vegetables, veal escalope with lemon, panna cotta and tiramisu, à la carte 30 euros.


La Closerie des Lilas, 171, boulevard Montparnasse. Tel. 014051-3450.

Open everyday till 1 AM.

Formerly a Café littéraire had as customers Baudelaire, Verlaine, Gide, Jarry, Apollinaire, Modigliani, Hemingway, Lenin and probably Trotsky. Keeps a litterary crowd of customers like Philippe Sollers. The present chef Jean-Pierre Cassagne has renovated the house and the excellent meals. Besides the restaurant there is `brasserie' where meals are alsoserved. Menu 43 euros (including wine), à la carte 90 euros.


Les Petites Sorcières, 12, rue Liancourt. Tel. 014321-9568.

Closed on saturdays and sundays and thursdays for lunch. Terrasse.Parisian bistrot. Recommended dishes: Tartare of Saint-Jacques with asparagus, braised filet of cod (cabillaud), roasted rabbit leg, strawberries gratin. Pleasent atmosphere. Menus: 18 euros (lunch) and à la carte 25 euros.



It is the oldest observatory still serving. In 1665 the physicist and astronomer Auzout convinced Colbert and Louis XIV to construct `l'Observatoire Royale'. It is built without wood (to avoid fire) or metal (to avoid magnetic disturbances). At the summer solstice of 1667, the orientation (north-south) is traced in its place by members of the Académie Royale.

Claude Perrault (the architect of the Louvre Colonnade) projected the building and directed its construction. It was finished in 1672. It is a large rectangle (31 m x 29 m) with its four faces oriented with the cardinal points of the compass. The latitude of the south face defines the Paris latitude (48° 50' 11''). The meridian line passing through its center defines the Paris longitude.

The foundations are as deep (27 m) as high is the building itself. The Observatoire is in charge of the French legal time: UTC(OP) and of the Central Bureau of the International Earth Rotation Service. In 1933, the first speaking clock in the world started to give the accurate time by telephone (tel. 3699) from the ground floor of the Observatoire.

The basement of the Observatoire is connected with the Paris catacombs (visits forbidden). The catacombs consist of 65 km of underground galleries. First, at the head of the Observatoire de Paris was Jean-Dominique Cassini (Cassini I), born in Italy in 1625. He was followed by his son Jacques (Cassini II), his grand-son César-François and his grand-grand-son Jean-Dominique.

The Observatoire was later leaded by Joseph Jerôme Lefrançois de Lalande, Pierre-André Méchain, François Arago (1843-1853), Urbain Le Verrier (1854-1870 and 1873-77) and other distinguished personalities.

Further illustrious scientists worked at the Observatoire like Jean-Baptiste Delambre, Charles Marie de La Condamine and Pierre Simon de Laplace.

One can mention as principals scientific works made in the Observatoire: The map of the Moon by Cassini I that was the best till the photography was invented. The discovery of the gap in the Saturne ring by Cassini I and the table of the satellites of Jupiter movements that allowed the danish astronomer Olaüs Römer to show that the speed of light was finite and compute approximately, for the first time in 1676 while he was working at the Observatoire.

Jacques Cassini discovered the proper motion of Arcturus, showing the first that the stars were not fixed.

César-François and Jean-Dominique (IV) Cassini made the first modern map of France from 1750 to 1790.

The units of mass (gramme) and length (meter) were defined following measurements (along the France meridian) and researches made at the Observatoire. Lavoisier worked here on the mass unit. Arago introduced here the photography in astronomy. In 1845 Hyppolite Fizeau and Léon Foucault obtained the first daguerreotype of the sun.

Foucault in 1850-51 showed manifestly the rotation of the earth with his pendulum hanging in the salle Cassini (after a first experiment at his home, and before the demonstration at the Panthéon).

The works by Le Verrier lead to the discovery of Neptune. His tables of sun and planets positions were used for more than one century.

Discrepancies remarked by him between the calculated and observed orbit of Mercury were only solved with the advent of general relativity.

The three main halls in the Observatoire are the `Grande Gallerie' and the `Salle du Conseil' in the ground floor and the Cassini hall in the first floor. In the `Salle du Conseil' are displayed the portraits of Laplace, Le Verrier, Lalande, Arago, Delambre, as well as other distinguished scientists and the one of Louis XIV.

At present the Observatoire de Paris owns three campuses: Paris, the Meudon astrophysics section and the radioastronomy station at Nançay. More than 700 scientists, technicians and administrative staff work there.


Nearby Historic Monuments

The Observatory Fountain (1873) by Davioud is known for its decoration of the four quarters of the globe by Carpeaux (Oceania was omitted for symmetry reasons).

Before the Closerie des Lilas café stands the statue of Marshal Ney by François Rude (1853). Ney was shot nearby in 1815 for his support of Napoleon. Rodin said that this was the nicest statue in Paris.

Inside the Baudelocque Maternity (123, boulevard Port Royal) remain some buildings from the Port Royal abbey. There is the nuns chapel (constructed by Le Pautre, 1646-47), the cloister Bernard were there from 1626 till 1664 when Louis XIV dispersed them due to their jansenist ideas.

Afterwards Visitandins nuns stay there till the French revolution. It become then a prison (Lavoisier was jailed here) and a Maternity since 1818. In the middle of the place Denfert-Rochereau is a small bronze version

of Bartholdi's Lion in commemoration of colonel Denfert-Rochereau successful defence of Belfort against the prussians in 1870-71.

In 1, Place Denfert-Rochereau there is the entrance of the Paris Catacombs. Several million skeletons are stored inside. The headquarters of the Résistance - F.F.I. (Interior French Forces) of the Ile-de-France commanded by colonel Henri Rol-Tanguy were here, inside the catacombs during the liberation of Paris in August 1944.

The elegant and vast hôtel Massa, (38, rue du Faubourg Saint-Jacques) was built in 1784 on the Champs-Elysées at the present location of the Virgin Megastore. The duke of Richelieu, the count Marescalchi and the duke of Massa lived there. In 1928 was moved here. It belongs to the Men of Letters Society. Honoré de Balzac lived from 1829 to 1834 at the house in 6, rue Cassini. He wrote there `Eugénie Grandet', `Le Père Goriot' and may be `La Peau de Chagrin'.



You can visit in Paris its classical landmarks Museums as the Louvre, Orsay, Picasso, Rodin, the recently open Museum of “Arts Premiers” and many others. In addition, some outstanding temporary expositions are held at the dates of the meeting. It is convenient to make reservations to visit in advance.

Musée du quai Branly, Arts Premiers: 37 quai Brainly, portail Debilly, 75007 Paris.

Fondation Henri Cartier-Bresson : 2 Impasse Lebouis, 75014 Paris. Tel: 01 56 80 27 00. Fax: 01 56 80 27 01.Métro Gaité, ligne 13,. Edgard Quinet, ligne 6.Bus Lignes 28, 58, 88.

Fondation Cartier pour l'art contemporain: 261, boulevard Raspail, 75014 Paris .Tel :33(0)1 42 18 56 50. Metro Denfert-Rochereau (lignes 4 et 6) or Metro Raspail (lignes 4 et 6), RER Denfert-Rochereau (ligne B) .Bus 38, 68, 91

Musée du Cinéma, Cinémathèque Française, 51 rue de Bercy, Paris .Tél : 01 71 19 33 33,Tél : 01 71 19 32 01, .Métro Bercy (lignes 6 et 14), bus 24.

Musée des Arts et Métiers: 60 rue Réaumur, 75003 Paris; Métro : Arts et Métiers, Réaumur-Sébastopol.Bus : 20, 38, 39, 47.Tél.: +33 (0)1 53 01 82 00. Fax : +33 (0)1 53 01 82 01. Musée National d'Art Moderne

htt:// Musée du Luxembourg: 19 rue de Vaugirard - 75006 Paris Metro : Saint-Sulpice, Odeon / RER B : Luxembourg Station Autobus : 84, 58, 89 - Musée du Luxembourg, Sènat Palais de Chaillot, 17, place du Trocadero, Metro : Trocadero, Bus : 22, 30, 32, 63, 72, 82, Batobus : Tour Eiffel .Bibliothèque Nationale de France, site F.-Mitterrand Paris 13ème. Metro Quai de la Gare, line 6 and RER C. Bus 89, 62 and 132.


International School of Astrophysics 'D.Chalonge'

Back to Chalonge School Page <>